Editorial verdict

Our answer

For control of an entire match, 2010/11 is the clearest answer: Messi as a false nine inside Barcelona's greatest midfield. For the broadest attacking version, 2014/15 has the counter-case, with Messi creating and finishing beside Suárez and Neymar.

Candidate 1

Barcelona 2008/09

The breakout superstar season. First Ballon d'Or, first treble, the 2009 Champions League final.

Open squad page →

Barcelona

2008/09

Pep Guardiola

  • UCL
  • League
  • Cup
93OVR

Starting XI

  • LWHENRY90
  • STETOO92
  • RWMESSI95
  • CMINIESTA94
  • CDMBUSQUETS84
  • CMXAVI95
  • LBABIDAL86
  • CBPUYOL90
  • CBPIQUE88
  • RBALVES90
  • GKVALDES86

Candidate 2

Barcelona 2010/11

False nine, Wembley, and a claim that this was the best club team ever built around him.

Open squad page →

Barcelona

2010/11

Pep Guardiola

  • UCL
  • League
94OVR

Starting XI

  • LWPEDRO86
  • STVILLA91
  • RWMESSI98
  • CMINIESTA95
  • CDMBUSQUETS91
  • CMXAVI96
  • LBABIDAL86
  • CBPUYOL89
  • CBPIQUE90
  • RBALVES91
  • GKVALDES87

Candidate 3

Barcelona 2014/15

MSN. Messi as creator-finisher alongside Suárez and Neymar in another treble year.

Open squad page →

Barcelona

2014/15

Luis Enrique

  • UCL
  • League
  • Cup
93OVR

Starting XI

  • LWNEYMAR93
  • STSUAREZ94
  • RWMESSI98
  • CMINIESTA90
  • CDMBUSQUETS90
  • CMRAKITIC87
  • LBALBA87
  • CBMASCHERANO86
  • CBPIQUE88
  • RBALVES88
  • GKBRAVO86

Settle it in the simulator

Barcelona 2008/09 vs Barcelona 2010/11

Open this dream match →

More era debates

Other primes worth arguing about