Editorial verdict

Our answer

The 1998/99 treble is United's defining achievement; the 2007/08 side is our pick for playing strength. Peak Ronaldo, Rooney and Tevez attacked ahead of Ferdinand and Vidić, giving Ferguson elite quality in every line.

Candidate 1

Manchester United 1998/99

The treble. Camp Nou, injury time, the most famous ending in club football.

Open squad page →

Manchester United

1998/99

Alex Ferguson

  • UCL
  • League
  • Cup
91OVR

Starting XI

  • STYORKE87
  • STCOLE86
  • LMGIGGS90
  • CMSCHOLES89
  • CMKEANE90
  • RMBECKHAM89
  • LBIRWIN85
  • CBJOHNSEN83
  • CBSTAM90
  • RBG.NEVILLE84
  • GKSCHMEICHEL92

Candidate 2

Manchester United 2007/08

Peak Ronaldo, Rooney and Tevez, Vidić and Ferdinand, a European Cup in Moscow.

Open squad page →

Manchester United

2007/08

Alex Ferguson

  • UCL
  • League
92OVR

Starting XI

  • STTEVEZ88
  • STROONEY91
  • LMGIGGS86
  • CMSCHOLES88
  • CMCARRICK86
  • RMRONALDO96
  • LBEVRA87
  • CBVIDIC90
  • CBFERDINAND91
  • RBBROWN82
  • GKVAN DER SAR91

Candidate 3

Manchester United 2025/26

Amorim's current rebuild. Not a prime — the 2025/26 squad you can throw at 1999 and 2008.

Open squad page →

Manchester United

2025/26

Rúben Amorim

82OVR

Starting XI

  • STSESKO84
  • CAMBRUNO88
  • CAMAMAD82
  • LWBDORGU78
  • CMUGARTE80
  • CMMAINOO82
  • RWBDALOT80
  • CBL.MARTINEZ84
  • CBDE LIGT84
  • CBYORO80
  • GKONANA80

Settle it in the simulator

Manchester United 1998/99 vs Manchester United 2007/08

Open this dream match →

More era debates

Other primes worth arguing about